Court Dismisses BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC Damages Claims Against Min Hee-jin

A Seoul court has rejected ₩2.5 billion in combined damages claims brought by the two HYBE labels, along with Min Hee-jin’s separate ₩5 billion counterclaim. Both companies say they intend to appeal.

News

The Desk · filed 2026-11-13

2 min read
Article sharing controls

Reported against primary sources.

The Seoul Western District Court has dismissed civil damages claims brought by BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin, delivering first-instance rulings on November 13 in disputes stemming from her public remarks during the 2024 HYBE–ADOR conflict.

The two HYBE-affiliated labels had sought a combined ₩2.5 billion in compensation, consisting of a ₩2 billion claim from BELIFT LAB and a separate ₩500 million claim from SOURCE MUSIC.

The court rejected both claims. It also dismissed a ₩5 billion counterclaim filed by Min against BELIFT LAB, meaning none of the three claims resulted in a damages award.

BELIFT LAB’s case

BELIFT LAB’s lawsuit followed Min’s April 2024 allegations that ILLIT had imitated elements of NewJeans’ creative identity, including aspects of its presentation and choreography.

The label disputed those allegations and argued that Min’s statements had damaged its reputation and interfered with its business.

In rejecting the damages claim, the court found that the disputed remarks amounted to subjective opinions or evaluations rather than actionable false statements of fact, according to reporting on the ruling.

That distinction is significant. The court’s dismissal does not establish that ILLIT plagiarized NewJeans; it addresses whether the statements created civil liability under the claims before the court.

Min’s own counterclaim against BELIFT LAB was also dismissed.

SOURCE MUSIC’s separate lawsuit

SOURCE MUSIC pursued ₩500 million in damages over Min’s remarks concerning the management of trainees and the circumstances surrounding the debuts of NewJeans and LE SSERAFIM.

The court likewise rejected that claim, with reporting indicating that the disputed statements did not establish the grounds required for the damages sought.

Although the cases arose from related public disputes, BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC pursued separate claims involving different statements.

Both labels plan to appeal

Following the decisions, BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC expressed disagreement with the rulings and announced their intention to appeal.

The decisions are first-instance civil judgments, not final appellate outcomes. An intention to appeal does not itself establish that an appeal has been formally filed.

The rulings also do not resolve separate criminal proceedings or the other legal disputes involving HYBE, ADOR and Min Hee-jin.

For now, the immediate outcome is clear: both companies’ damages claims and Min’s counterclaim have been rejected at first instance, leaving any further challenge to the appellate process.

Article sharing controls

Reporting & Verification

Verified by: The Desk (Editorial Desk)

Cross-checked the November 13 first-instance dismissals, three claim amounts and announced appeal intentions against contemporaneous Korean courtroom and legal reporting.

Our Editorial Standards

Filings

Sources cross-checked for this story (3 sources)

  1. 01

    StarNews — Original November 13 courtroom reporting

    https://www.starnewskorea.com/star/2026/11/13/2026111316375337823
  2. 02

    Maeil Business Newspaper — Report

    https://www.mk.co.kr/en/musics/12208313
  3. 03

From readers

The desk’s comment thread

Signed-in members can post, reply, and upvote. Verified bylines stay on the article itself — the thread below is where readers talk back.