NewJeans Contracts Draw Scrutiny Over Youth Protections and AI Rights as ADOR Responds

A New York Times investigation details disputed provisions in contracts signed when the members were teenagers, prompting a point-by-point response from ADOR.

News

The Desk · filed 2026-11-06

3 min read
Article sharing controls

Reported against primary sources.

Updated November 6, 2026

A November 5 investigation by The New York Times has brought renewed scrutiny to NewJeans’ contracts with ADOR, detailing provisions concerning protections for young performers, restrictions on personal conduct and the use of artists’ identities after their agreements end.

According to the investigation, the contracts were signed in 2022, when the members were between 14 and 17 years old. The reported agreements omitted certain protections included in South Korea’s government-standard entertainment contract template, including language addressing education and physical and mental well-being.

The report also describes restrictions governing conduct, romantic relationships and public statements about the company. Other provisions reportedly address the financial consequences of contract termination and the label’s ability to commercially use members’ names, images and voices, including AI-generated representations, beyond the original agreement period.

ADOR issued a detailed response on November 6 disputing the investigation’s characterization of the contracts.

The company said HYBE-affiliated labels use standard supplementary agreements for young trainees covering education, rest, sleep and personal rights. It maintained that NewJeans’ exclusive contracts also contain broader human-rights protections.

ADOR further stated that the contracts followed several months of negotiations involving the members, their parents and legal representatives. It defended the termination-payment formula as consistent in effect with the government standard and said any use of AI-generated content requires individual consent.

The agency also disputed the suggestion that it intended to use former artists’ identities without authorization, emphasizing the need to comply with applicable law.

The reported provisions add a new dimension to the longstanding NewJeans–ADOR dispute, particularly concerning the contractual treatment of performers who began their careers as minors.

The investigation’s findings and ADOR’s rebuttal are competing accounts of the agreements’ meaning and application. The reporting does not establish a new judicial finding that the contracts violated child-protection laws, nor does it establish that AI-generated versions of the members have been deployed.

New Update:

Min Hee-jin’s Representatives Dispute HYBE’s Account of Contract Authority

Following HYBE and ADOR’s response, representatives for former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin issued a separate statement on November 6 challenging the company’s description of who held responsibility for NewJeans’ contracts.

Min’s side argued that HYBE’s legal department prepared the initial exclusive-contract drafts and directed subsequent revisions.

According to the statement, ADOR did not have an independent legal team at the time, and the contracts required review and approval from HYBE’s legal department, chief financial officer and chief executive, alongside approval from ADOR’s board.

Her representatives acknowledged that negotiations took place over several months and involved discussions with the members, their parents and legal representatives.

However, they argued that participation in those negotiations did not mean ADOR had independent authority over the contracts’ fundamental terms or final approval.

Min’s side also disputed HYBE’s account of the clauses concerning the artists’ image and voice rights, claiming that HYBE’s legal department prepared the relevant provisions.

HYBE and ADOR have maintained that the contracts were negotiated with the involvement of Min, the members, their families and legal representatives, and that supplementary agreements provided protections for underage artists.

ADOR has also stated that any AI-related use of an artist’s image or voice requires the individual’s consent.

The competing statements leave responsibility for the drafting and approval process disputed. Neither account establishes a new judicial determination regarding the contracts’ legality or the parties’ respective responsibilities.

Article sharing controls

Reporting & Verification

Verified by: The Desk (Editorial Desk)

The November 5 investigation’s reported findings were cross-checked against contemporary coverage and ADOR’s detailed November 6 response; the underlying contracts were not independently inspected.

Our Editorial Standards

Filings

Sources cross-checked for this story (4 sources)

  1. 01
  2. 02
  3. 03
  4. 04

From readers

The desk’s comment thread

Signed-in members can post, reply, and upvote. Verified bylines stay on the article itself — the thread below is where readers talk back.